Wyoming LLC or Delaware C corporation? Three points AI founders often misunderstand
This guide is part of the AI and software founders series.
In brief
- The state where a company is formed sets its legal home and its formation and annual report costs. It does not decide where the company pays income or franchise tax. That follows where the business is managed and where it earns income.
- A Delaware C corporation is a separate federal taxpayer and is the structure outside investors usually expect. A Wyoming LLC is, by default, taxed to its owners, which can suit a business funded by its own revenue.
- A U.S. LLC with one foreign owner files with the IRS in any year it has reportable transactions with its owner or another related party: Form 5472, the information return for 25% foreign-owned U.S. companies, attached to a pro forma Form 1120. In practice that is most years, because money the owner puts in or takes out counts, but a year with no reportable transactions has no filing. The penalty for not filing when required is generally $25,000.
- A company managed from the Bay Area is commercially domiciled in California. It is doing business in California at any revenue level and owes at least the $800 annual tax. An LLC may also owe the LLC fee.
- Choosing an entity is a legal decision as well as a tax one. Please consult an attorney on entity choice.
How do a Delaware C corporation and a Wyoming LLC differ for a non-U.S. founder?
They differ mainly in who the taxpayer is. A C corporation pays tax itself. An LLC, unless it elects otherwise, passes its income to its owners.
| Delaware C corporation | Wyoming LLC (default tax treatment) | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical use | Raising money from outside investors | A business funded by its own revenue |
| Federal taxpayer | The corporation, at 21% of taxable income | The owner or owners. One owner: disregarded entity. Two or more: partnership. |
| Money going to a foreign owner | Dividends are generally subject to 30% U.S. withholding, or a lower rate under a tax treaty | A foreign owner is generally taxed in the U.S. on income effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business, and files a U.S. return if there is any |
| Annual federal information return when foreign-owned | Form 5472 with Form 1120, when there are reportable transactions with related parties | Single foreign owner: Form 5472 with a pro forma Form 1120, in any year with reportable transactions with the owner or another related party |
| Investor expectations | Standard for venture financing. Only C corporation stock can qualify as QSBS. | Less common. Converting later is possible but has tax consequences. |
| Managed from California | Registers in California. $800 minimum franchise tax from the second year, and 8.84% of California net income. | Registers in California. $800 annual tax from the first year, plus the LLC fee if total California income is $250,000 or more. |
State formation and annual report fees for Delaware, Wyoming and California are listed in Forming an LLC or corporation in California. QSBS, the federal exclusion for qualified small business stock, is covered in QSBS after the 2025 tax law.
Misconception 1: "Forming in Wyoming lowers the tax bill"
Wyoming has no state income tax on companies, and its annual report license tax is low. That benefit applies to a business that actually operates in Wyoming.
A company formed in Wyoming but run from somewhere else is taxed where it is run and where it earns income. Federal tax is the same in every state. The usual result of forming in a low-tax state while operating in California is two sets of state filings: Wyoming's annual report, plus California's registration, returns and tax.
Misconception 2: "A foreign-owned LLC with no U.S. income has nothing to file"
It generally does. A U.S. LLC wholly owned by one foreign person is treated as a corporation for the limited purpose of Form 5472. Reportable transactions include money the owner puts into or takes out of the LLC, so a company with no revenue can still have a filing.
The LLC files a pro forma Form 1120 with Form 5472 attached by the due date of that return. The IRS states that a penalty of $25,000 may apply for each failure to file a complete and correct Form 5472 on time.
Whether the owner also owes U.S. income tax is a separate question. It generally depends on whether the LLC's income is effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business, which turns on where the people, offices and activities are. See Form 5472 for a foreign-owned LLC with no revenue.
Misconception 3: "California cannot tax a company formed in another state"
California taxes a company based on what it does in California, not where its papers were filed. Under the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) rules, a business is doing business in California if it meets any one of these tests:
- It engages in any transaction for financial gain in California.
- It is organized or commercially domiciled in California.
- Its California sales, property or payroll exceed the annual thresholds. For 2025, these are $757,070 of sales, $75,707 of property or $75,707 of payroll, or 25% of the company's total in that category if lower. The FTB had not listed 2026 amounts on its "Doing business in California" page when this article was prepared.
Commercial domicile is the principal place from which the business is directed or managed. If the founders make decisions, sign contracts and manage the team from an office or home in the Bay Area, the company's commercial domicile is in California. Revenue does not matter for this test. A pre-revenue startup meets it.
The consequences for an out-of-state entity doing business in California:
- Registration with the California Secretary of State as a foreign (out-of-state) entity.
- Corporation: California franchise tax at 8.84% of California net income, with an $800 minimum. A newly registered corporation is not subject to the minimum in its first taxable year.
- LLC: the $800 annual tax, due by the 15th day of the 4th month after it begins doing business or registers, with no first-year exemption for LLCs formed in 2026. An LLC also pays the LLC fee based on total California income:
| Total California income | LLC fee |
|---|---|
| $250,000 to $499,999 | $900 |
| $500,000 to $999,999 | $2,500 |
| $1,000,000 to $4,999,999 | $6,000 |
| $5,000,000 or more | $11,790 |
The LLC fee is measured on income before expenses, so an LLC with a loss can still owe it. The estimated fee is due by the 15th day of the 6th month of the tax year on form FTB 3536.
What if the founders and the team are all outside the U.S.?
Then commercial domicile is generally not in California, and the analysis changes. The company can still be doing business in California if it has employees, contractors acting for it, or property there, or if its California sales exceed the threshold above.
Sales tax is separate from all of this. A company with no California presence can still have to collect tax on software sold to California customers. See SaaS sales tax by state.
Worked example (example numbers only)
Two founders live in San Jose and run a SaaS product from there with four employees. On advice from a forum, they formed a Wyoming LLC. Total income for the year is $1,200,000, of which $600,000 is California income.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Wyoming annual report license tax (minimum) | $60 |
| California annual LLC tax | $800 |
| California LLC fee ($500,000 to $999,999 tier) | $2,500 |
| California total | $3,300 |
The Wyoming filing did not replace anything in California. It added a second state's annual report and a registered agent. The members also report the LLC's income on their own returns.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a Delaware C corporation run from the Bay Area pay California tax?
Yes. It is commercially domiciled in California, so it is doing business there. It registers with the California Secretary of State, files a California return, and pays franchise tax on its California net income, subject to the $800 minimum after its first taxable year.
Can a Wyoming LLC avoid California's $800 tax if it has no revenue yet?
Not if it is managed from California. The commercial domicile test does not depend on revenue. An LLC that is doing business in California owes the $800 annual tax whether or not it has income.
Is a Wyoming LLC a good choice for founders who live in China?
It depends on the facts, and there is no default answer. Relevant points include who the owners are, where work is performed, whether outside investment is planned, and how the owners will take money out. A foreign-owned LLC generally has a U.S. filing in any year with reportable transactions, which in practice is most years. Please consult an attorney on entity choice.
Can an LLC convert to a Delaware C corporation later?
Generally yes, and many companies do so before a priced financing round. A conversion can have tax consequences for the company and its owners, and the timing affects items such as QSBS. Review it with your attorney and tax adviser before signing a term sheet.
How COOP can help
We explain the U.S. tax effect of each structure before you form, so that you and your attorney can decide with the numbers in front of you. After formation we handle the annual federal and California filings, including Form 5472 for foreign-owned companies. Book a free consultation for a free 15-minute call.
Official Sources
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice for your situation. Rules change and depend on your facts; please consult a qualified professional before acting.